Ai mới là đối tượng bị tổn thương?

(Baothanhhoa.vn) - Những ngày này, câu chuyện gian lận điểm trong kỳ thi THPT quốc gia 2018 tại tỉnh Hòa Bình đã và đang nhận được rất nhiều sự quan tâm từ phía dư luận cả nước. Cùng với những cái lắc đầu ngán ngẩm về sự xuống cấp của đạo đức giáo dục, truyền thông nước nhà còn dấy lên câu hỏi: Nên hay không nên công khai danh tính 64 “sinh viên dởm”?

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

Bình luận

Xin vui lòng gõ tiếng Việt có dấu

Tin cùng chuyên mục

Chứng nhận tín nhiệm mạng
Việt Long Phần mềm tòa soạn
hội tụ thông minh